Your Outside Counsel Uses AI. Why Are You Still Paying by the Hour?

What ABA Formal Opinion 512 means for legal billing, AI transparency, and the future of outside counsel relationships.

Generative AI is becoming part of everyday legal practice, from contract review and legal research to drafting and document analysis. But are clients seeing the benefits in their legal bills?

ABA Formal Opinion 512 makes one thing clear: lawyers who bill by the hour must charge for the time they actually spend, not the hours an AI tool eliminated. In fact, reputed law firms like Baker McKenzie are already rethinking the billable hour and exploring value-based pricing models.

If your outside counsel still bills as if every task takes the same time it did in 2019, you may be subsidizing their efficiency gains. Under an hourly arrangement, there is no ethical justification for billing hours that were never worked.

For general counsel (GCs), this raises a practical question: Are your outside counsel billing arrangements keeping pace with AI?

What ABA Formal Opinion 512 Actually Says About AI Billing

Issued in July 2024 by the ABA Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility, Formal Opinion 512 is the ABA’s first formal ethics opinion specifically addressing generative AI.

It creates no new rules. Instead, it applies existing ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct to AI use. 

The relevant duties include competence, confidentiality, client communication, supervision, candor, and — critically for this discussion — reasonable fees under Model Rule 1.5. 

On fees, the opinion is direct: lawyers who bill by the hour “must bill for their actual time.”

If a generative AI tool reduces a four-hour drafting assignment to 25 minutes of prompting plus careful lawyer review, the client is billed for the actual time reasonably spent. The hours the technology saved do not appear on the invoice.

The opinion offers a straightforward illustration: a lawyer spends 15 minutes entering information into an AI tool to prepare a pleading. The lawyer may bill for those 15 minutes, plus the time spent reviewing the resulting draft for accuracy and completeness — but not for the hours the task might previously have required.

A second, equally important point: a firm generally may not charge clients for learning how to use AI tools it intends to employ regularly.

Staying competent with the tools of modern legal practice is a firm responsibility. A limited exception applies when a client specifically requests an unfamiliar tool for a particular matter and the parties appropriately agree on the training charges.

Why This Matters for General Counsel

Many engagement letters and outside counsel guidelines still say nothing about generative AI.

That silence may leave clients uncertain about how AI-driven efficiencies, technology expenses, and AI-assisted work are reflected in their invoices.

Sophisticated legal departments that update their engagement terms can establish clearer expectations about billing, transparency, and accountability. Those that do not may leave money on the table.

This is not an anti-law-firm position.

Firms that use generative AI effectively and bill transparently can strengthen client relationships. Firms that try to preserve billable hours that technology has eliminated risk uncomfortable questions from clients who understand Opinion 512.

What Belongs in Your Engagement Letters and Outside Counsel Guidelines

Three concrete provisions can reduce ambiguity and protect both sides.

1. Clear AI Disclosure Language

State that generative AI tools may be used on the matter, that the firm remains responsible for its work product, and the circumstances requiring client notification or consent.

Disclosure is not automatically required for every AI-assisted task. Under Model Rule 1.4, the circumstances determine when communication is required. Confidentiality obligations under Rule 1.6 may separately require informed consent, particularly when AI tools create material risks of exposing client information.

Importantly, generic engagement-letter language does not substitute for informed consent when the ethics rules require it.

2. Actual-Time Billing When AI Is Used

Confirm that hourly fees reflect only the time reasonably expended by firm personnel, including prompting AI tools, reviewing outputs, editing drafts, verifying information, and exercising professional judgment.

AI-generated output is not itself a billable hour.

Under an hourly arrangement, AI-driven time savings should be reflected in the hours charged to the client.

3. No Charging for the Firm’s Learning Curve or Ordinary Tool Costs

Time spent training personnel on AI tools the firm regularly uses should generally not be charged to clients.

Ordinary technology subscriptions that function as firm overhead should also be distinguished from legitimate matter-specific expenses.

AI-related charges must be reasonable, transparently explained, and appropriately agreed upon in advance.

Sample Engagement-Letter Language

Consider adapting these provisions to your organization’s outside counsel guidelines:

AI Use and Accountability

“The Firm may use generative AI tools in the course of the representation. The Firm remains responsible for the accuracy, completeness, and quality of its work product and will obtain the Client’s informed consent where required by applicable professional responsibility rules.”

AI-Assisted Hourly Billing

“Hourly fees will be charged only for time actually and reasonably expended by Firm personnel, including time spent prompting AI tools and reviewing, verifying, and revising their output.”

AI Training and Technology Expenses

“Time spent training personnel on AI tools used in the ordinary course of the Firm’s practice, and ordinary subscription costs for such tools, will not be charged separately to the Client. Any exceptional training or matter-specific technology charges must be disclosed and agreed upon in advance.”

These provisions are starting points, not substitutes for jurisdiction-specific review.

For Law Firm Partners: Turning AI Efficiency into Competitive Advantage

For managing partners and practice leaders, the challenge is not simply compliance. It is rethinking how firms capture the value of their expertise.

AI-enabled productivity can improve turnaround times, increase capacity, and support alternative fee arrangements that reward professional judgment rather than the duration of routine tasks.

Fixed fees, phased pricing, and hybrid arrangements offer possibilities, provided the resulting charges remain reasonable under applicable ethics rules.

The goal is not to make legal services cheaper at any cost. It is to make the relationship between fees, value, and professional judgment more transparent.

Firms that embrace that shift can turn AI adoption into a competitive advantage rather than a threat to profitability.

The Practical Bottom Line

ABA Formal Opinion 512 does not require firms to abandon hourly billing. It does reinforce that hourly bills must reflect actual time spent when generative AI becomes part of the workflow.

For GCs, updating engagement letters and outside counsel guidelines puts those expectations in writing.

For law firm partners and practice leaders, aligning billing practices with AI-enabled workflows protects client relationships and demonstrates that efficiency and ethics can travel together.

AI does not make professional legal judgment less valuable. It makes the relationship between time, expertise, and legal fees harder to ignore.

If your current engagement letters are silent on generative AI and actual-time billing, the gap is worth addressing now.

The firms that close it first will be easier to work with — and harder to replace.


Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. ABA Formal Opinion 512 provides advisory ethics guidance based on the ABA Model Rules. Binding professional responsibility requirements may vary by jurisdiction.